Warning: This article contains SPOILERS for The Stolen Girl episode 2After establishing its core mystery in the pilot, I was excited to see howThe Stolen Girlepisode 2 would differentiate itself from other shows in the genre. So far, there is nothing that particularly stands out about the series, despite offering some decent entertainment. While I’ll admit I’m invested in a few characters, none of them linger in my mind after the credits roll. There are moments that caught me by surprise, including the opening scene when Lucia (Beatrice Campbell) is taken, but I still want more from this miniseries.
I may have too high expectations for a five-episode show that can only go in a limited number of directions. Yet, Denise Gough’s (Andor) portrayal of a desperate, guilt-ridden mother givesThe Stolen Girla notable depth that can be further utilized. If the psychological drama continues to focus on Elisa’s experience, as well as her slowly developing camaraderie with Selma (Ambika Mod,Netflix’sOne Day), it will hold my attention. Fred’s (Jim Sturgess) storyline, however, is one I wouldn’t hesitate to exchange for more scenes with the female leads.
Fred’s Storyline In The Stolen Girl Episode 2 Is Dull, But Relevant
His Job Could Theoretically Connect To Lucia’s Kidnapping
There’s no valid reason for Fred to go to work amid the major crisis unless it relates back to the search for his daughter. Elisa pleads with her husband to stay home, but he insists he needs to be with his client during questioning. Audiences feel Elisa’s desperation in the moment, angry at Fred for ignoring such a simple request.
Regardless of why he goes into the office, Fred needs to be transparent with his wife, especially when Lucia’s kidnapping could be a result of his emotional infidelity.
Due to the nature of his job, it’s plausible that Lucia is being used as leverage in a past or current case. It would be an oversight not to explore the possibility, but the necessity of the entire plotline is questionable. Its relevance is a result of the career the series has chosen for Fred, and, depending on how things progress, may only be addressed out of obligation. Hisrole as a criminal attorneyfeels like a pointless way to fill screentime that could be better utilized elsewhere.
If one of Fred’s clients is related to Lucia’s disappearance, the revelation would be an underwhelming conclusion toThe Stolen Girl’smain mystery. No matter the angle, nothing worthwhile has come from Fred’s current story. The plot keeps him physically away from Elisain episode 2, but there’s already an emotional distance between them that yields the same result.
Elisa & Selma Carry The Stolen Girl’s Emotional Weight
They Stand Out In A Cast Of Two-Dimensional Characters
Whether Selma is more invested in breaking a story or finding Lucia is up for interpretation, but it’s easy to connect with a characterwho has untapped potential. She jumps at the opportunity to escape the pig-centered headline she’s working on when Elisa posts a photo of her daughter on social media. While Elisa initially rejects Selma’s help, the reporter identifies the woman who delivered the ransom note. Able to achieve what the police cannot, there’s no denying that her investigation skills can bring them closer to locating the missing child.
When Gough and Mod are onscreen, I feelgenuinely engaged with the seriesand curious about what’s next. Whichever form of camaraderie develops between the characters, Selma’s secret investigation into Elisa’s history makes a potential friendship even more intriguing. While Episode 2 ends with a major break in the case, I’m more interested in how the women will react to the news, rather than Rebecca’s motivation and whereabouts. Despite being bored with Fred’s chosen storyline, I’m excited for Elisa and Selma’s hopeful teamup.
The Stolen Girlis available to stream on Disney+ worldwide with new episodes airing Wednesdays at 10 p.m. ET on Freeform.
The Stolen Girl Episode 2
The Stolen Girl is a 2025 drama-thriller that unfolds the life of a mother whose reality is shattered after allowing her nine-year-old daughter to attend a sleepover at a new friend’s home. The narrative delves into the tense and unpredictable journey that emerges following this decision.
