Although the appearance of Steve Carell’s Michael Scott changed radically after season 1 ofThe Office, this transformation was more than skin-deep. While theoriginal UK sitcomTheOfficewas a beloved cult hit, the cynical British sitcom had a hard time traveling overseas. Later British sitcoms likeThe IT CrowdandThe Inbetweenerswere disastrous failures when transplanted to the US, but the US take onThe Officewas critically acclaimed, adored by fans, and lasted a staggering nine seasons.
However,The Office’s journey from a hit British sitcom to a successful US comedy show was a tough, complicated one.The first season ofThe Officeis infamously hard to watch, leaning far too hard into mean-spirited cringe comedy and lacking both the heart and the cartoony humor that made later seasons so memorable. At first,the US take onThe Officestrived to be as faithful to the original show as possible, and the result was a downbeat, dour show where failure was the order of the day.
Why Steve Carell’s Michael Looked Different After The Office Season 1
Michael Scott Was No Longer Made To Resemble David Brent After Season 1
InThe Officeseason 1, the main characters seemed to authentically resent each other, and the eventual shift in their personalities is particularly evident in the characterization of Steve Carell’s Michael Scott.Carell’s Scott changes his appearance almost completely afterThe Officeseason 1, no longer working in shirts but instead wearing a full business suit. Despite his hapless persona, his haircut and clothing are sharper, providing a comical contrast with his buffoonish antics.
Originally, Micheal was clearly based on the original UK show’s main character, David Brent.
It is a lot funnier to see Carell’s bumbling goofball spout nonsense and pratfall while dressed for success than it was to see him as an unkempt, stressed-looking middle manager. Vitally, this change also lined up with a big switch in the personality ofThe Office’s Michael Scott. Originally, Micheal was clearly based on the original UK show’s main character, David Brent. Like so many iconic characters from British sitcoms, Brent was an abrasive, often outright irritating presence.
Viewers were encouraged to root for the boorish Brent’s downfall and, in an extensive oral history celebratingThe Office’s 20th anniversary, showrunner Geg Daniels admitted that this was also the original point of Carell’s character. Daniels toldThe Hollywood Reporterthat, in season 1, “He was not a good person.” As the sitcom continued, Daniels said the writers began “Nudging him from a person who is not part of your group, and you don’t really like them, to a person who you’re frustrated with often, but is part of your group. He’s more of the frustrating uncle or something.”
Steve Carell’s New Look Illustrated A Bigger Michael Scott Change
Moving Away From Rick Gervais’ UK Office Character Made Michael Better
With Michael’s new appearance in season 2 came a broader change in the character.Michael Scott was no longer just a copy of David Brent,but an original character from season 2 onward, with a much more likable personality and sympathetic portrayal. He remained hilariously frustrating and delusional right untilSteve Carell’s exit fromThe Office, but Michael was now an essentially decent, kind character whose ignorance, small-mindedness, and desperation to impress were his flaws, not his defining traits.
Carell’s character is arguably the sweetest cast member ofThe Officedespite his glaringly obvious issues.
Gervais’ Brent remains almost impressively insufferable throughout the UK version ofThe Office, and most of the show’s sweetest moments come from other characters. In contrast, Carell’s character is arguably the sweetest cast member ofThe Officedespite his glaringly obvious issues. Carell’s Scott became an endearing figure of fun who, although he almost always made the wrong decision or said the wrong thing, usually had the right motives and wanted the best for everyone.
Changing Michael’s Character Was Key For The Office US To Find Its Identity
Michael Scott’s Character Shift Was Echoed Throughout The Office US
Changing Michael proved surprisingly pivotal to the future success ofThe Office, as the show only hit its stride after Michael’s character shift happened.The worst episodes ofThe Officewere too cartoony for their own good, but many classic outings benefited from a goofy, silly tone that is largely absent in the grounded first season. AsThe Office’s Michael became more amiable, the show’s tone lost the edge of its British counterpart and settled into something sweeter and sillier.
Michael never stopped getting into major scrapes and causing chaos for the rest of the show’s heroes, butit became easier to root for Michael Scott the longerThe Officewent on. His character flaws were smoothed out and, while he was still constantly coming out with cringeworthy comments, everyone knew he meant well. Meanwhile, Michael’s surprising talent with sales proved he did have some unexpected depths, and his kindness toward his coworkers and his eventual love interest, Holly Flax, alike showed thatThe Office’s antihero was far from the odious character introduced in season 1.
